The Kingdom: Movie Review (2007)
(Originally published 2007)
Directed by Peter Berg, written by Matthew Michael Carnahan, 110 minutes, rated R.
The new Peter Berg movie, "The Kingdom," is at its best in its opening moments. We're in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, and there, on a ball field, several American oil workers and their families have gathered to play ball within the confines of their compound.
Everything appears to be going well--you can almost smell the hot dogs, the good cheer, the apple pie--until the playing field becomes a battlefield, with the Americans being gunned down by a terrorist cell apparently tapped by Allah to do their dirty work.
Suicide bombers detonate themselves. Chaos erupts. Limbs and other assorted body parts hurl themselves at the screen.
It's an ugly, violent opening that recalls the 1996 Khobar Towers bombing, but since this is a big-budget Hollywood movie released on the cusp of awards season, you sense the rest of the movie could go one of two ways.
Either America is going to open one big can of whup ass and defeat this cell (otherwise knows as the commercial way), or the movie is going to dig into the trenches and intelligently grapple with what occurred, why it occurred, and seek out those responsible and bring them to justice (otherwise known as the award-winning way).
Initially, it appears as if the movie is going to shoot for the latter, but unfortunately, since shooting for box office gold is this film's real priority, it goes for the former, with the FBI, which lost two agents to the attack, taking the case.
Not that they're exactly given the green light to do so. In this movie, FBI Special Agent Ronald Fleury (Jamie Foxx) goes against the government's wishes and leads three colleagues--Jennifer Garner as a forensics specialist, Chris Cooper as a bomb expert and Jason Bateman as the intelligence guru--in a covert trip overseas.
There, they are met with the sort of opposition meant to stymie them, but which they eventually work around thanks to the Saudi colonel (Ashraf Barhom) assigned to watch and protect them. Initially, he does so with gruff assertiveness. But then, as he comes to question his country because, you know, these Americans who know nothing about Saudi Arabia (they don't even know the language) have gleaned within 48 hours the sort of critical insights he himself hasn't been able to do in a lifetime, he starts to listen to them and help.
If that carries with it a whiff of condescension, well, "The Kingdom" is filled with it. It also is filled with its share of impressive action sequences, which are the film's best selling points. At least it does them right.
But as the film reveals itself to be increasingly, disappointingly manipulative and obvious, you see it for what it is--purely opportunistic, trading off our war in the Middle East and the fears surrounding it while offering audiences a pro and con look at the Arab community that grates with its black-and-white simplicity. There is no shading here, no gray tones, just a movie designed by those and for those who get their information from headlines and soundbites, nothing more substantial.
If this film underscores anything, it's just how deeply we still misunderstand the Middle East and how our culture--in this case, pop culture--completely misses complexities it can't even begin to understand.
Grade: D+
Technorati tags:
movie reviewsmovie-reviewsmoviesfilmfilm reviewsdramaaction
October 2, 2007 at 1:18 AM
I bet you never said that Americans misunderstood Cubans because of scarface, or Italians cause of the godfather, or germans couse of Private ryan. Why is it that its so offensive to you when an arab is a bad guy. Not everyone in the US is oblivious to the middle east like you think, we know that they're not all a bunch of savages. Its just a movie where saudies are bad guys. Next week someone else will be the bad guy.
By the way you show your condescension towards Americans in this line. "you can almost smell the hot dogs, the good cheer, the apple pie". as if thats all that represents America. thus you are guilty of the blanket characterizations and misunderstanding that you claim this movie does.
Where is your objectivity?
October 2, 2007 at 7:46 AM
Wow. You're reading a lot of your own baggage into this review. I don't think anywhere in this review did he say it was offensive that an Arab was the bad guy. Also, you're missing the point. The MOVIE is going to base elements of what America is by having us cloaked in the smells of hot dogs and apple pie. THEY are guilty, as you say, of such "blanket characterizations." I saw this movie, too, and felt just as manipulated as Christopher did. It's using the current war to sell tickets. Give me a break, can't you see that? Hollywood is profiting on this!
October 10, 2007 at 12:53 AM
your last paragraph doesn't even make sense. aren't you contradicting yourself by critisizing our culture for not understanding middle eastern culture, and then stating that we couldn't possibly understand middle eastern culture? which is it? whatever. it was a deeply flawed, engrossing and timely film. the middle eastern characters were compelling and humanistic. there are two sides to this conflict, and berg did no diservice to either with his film...
October 10, 2007 at 8:01 AM
You should all open your eyes and read a new book called "Paramedic to the prince" written by an American Paramedic that was on the medical team of King Abdullah. Really tells you what Saudi is really like. No American has ever been this close to the King andd written a book. It is banned in Saudi arabia. A really good reason to read it.
October 13, 2007 at 12:33 PM
This is an excellent review. The Kingdom begins with an intriguing premise, and devolves into a messy, Ramboesque action flick. This is a complete shame, because the movie initially makes an attempt to approach the situation with some degree of seriousness. The actors do what they can with their lines (with the Saudi police officers giving quite compelling turns), but ultimately the script destroys this movie. Instead of offering morally ambigious and complex characters and plot lines, we are force fed trite black and white generalities. A complex situation such as Middle East politics becomes portrayed as Us Vs Them. There is no nuance here, no thought-provoking insights (other than surface level connections). But given the current decisions made by our leaders, maybe this line of thinking is closer to reality than we would like to believe.
January 14, 2011 at 9:57 PM
I loved your blog. Thank you.